top of page

Arizona Mining: A Deep Discount to NPV

Writer's picture: SmallCapInvestorSmallCapInvestor

Arizona Mining (AZ.TO) has been one of the highest quality growth stories in the junior mining sector and is up over 500% since our initial investment last year. The company has made significant progress on its flagship Hermosa-Taylor project, quickly developing it into one of the largest zinc equivalent deposits in the world. Despite this, in recent months AZ's stock has been the subject of heavy selling pressure, falling from its peak of $3.49 in December to settle in the $2.20-$2.30 range. Last week, on April 4th, 2017, the company released its long-awaited PEA. Many investors believed the PEA would be closely followed by a sharp movement in the price of AZ stock, but there has been little to no reaction from the market in the days following its release, despite the positive results. In my opinion, the market's lack of response to the PEA has created a significant value opportunity for investors. In addition, I believe there is an overemphasis on project risks and a resulting undervaluation.

 

Preliminary Economic Assessment (PEA)

A Preliminary Economic Assessment or "PEA" is an economic analysis of a potential mineral project to determine the viability of its mineral resources. The PEA is usually one of the first steps a mining will go through in transitioning from an explorer to a mid-tier junior miner. In terms of confidence level and predictability of resources, the PEA is subordinate to a "Feasibility Study" but it is still a primary catalyst for movement in a mining company’s share price. 

The Hermosa-Taylor PEA contained the following highlights ($USD):

- Substantial NPV8% of $1.26 billion 

- Robust after-tax IRR of 42%

- Initial capex of $457 million

- Short 1.7 year payback

- Total operating costs of $48/ton

- 19 year mine life based on conservative 60.8 million tons of ore production


If this your first time reading PEA results, I can assure you that these are excellent numbers. A substantial NPV value, robust IRR, short payback period, and relatively low capital costs are all considered to be attractive project features in the eyes of mining developers and financiers. 


Net Present Value (NPV)


Net Present Value or "NPV" is the most commonly used metric to evaluate potential mining projects. It measures the expected change in company value as a result of undertaking the project at hand. In layman's terms, if you took all the minerals in deposit, all the costs and incomes, and processed the entire thing right now, the resulting value would be the NPV. In the case of Hermosa-Taylor, this value is USD$1.26 billion or CAD$1.69 billion of additional value for the firm and its shareholders; on a per share basis, this is roughly ~$6.75 CAD. At the time of this article, the stock price of Arizona Mining is $2.22 per share, representing a 66% discount to their NPV. It is not uncommon to find junior mining companies trading at a significant discount to their NPV. This discount reflects the various risks and potential pitfalls that can arise over the life of a project. The discount may also reflect the possibility of any future shareholder dilution, as most mining companies will need to raise additional funds in the form of equity in order to advance to the production stage. As a project gets closer to production, the various risks become less relevant and the discount to NPV is gradually reduced.

Internal Rate of Return (IRR)


The Internal Rate of Return or IRR is another metric used to measure the profitability of a potential project. The IRR is a bit more difficult to understand than the NPV. As in investor, what you need to know is that a higher IRR is desired. Also the minimally acceptable levels for IRR that mining developers like to see are also important. Projects with an IRR of less than 10% are not usually advanced to the production stage. The IRR for the Hermosa-Taylor deposit is well over this threshold, at 42%.  

Capital Expenditures (CAPEX)


Capital Expenditures or 'CAPEX' consists of all the costs that will need to be incurred in order to develop the deposit and extract its resources. This number is especially important for developers and financiers of a project, as they will not usually proceed if the NPV is less than or equal to CAPEX, as these projects are considered to be much riskier. The CAPEX for the Hermosa-Taylor deposit is $457 million. As with NPV, the CAPEX of a project is also an important measure but is less useful when viewed in isolation. Comparing the ratio of NPV to CAPEX provides a more useful tool for evaluation.

NPV/CAPEX Ratio


This ratio compares the additional value created over the project’s life to costs that will need to be incurred. This ratio is extremely important to developers and financiers of a mining project as they will not usually invest in projects with an NPV/CAPEX of less than 1. The Hermosa-Taylor deposit features an NPV/CAPEX ratio of around 2.75. In other words, the additional value that the Hermosa-Taylor will create is nearly triple to that of its costs, a very attractive feature in the eyes of mining developers.



Key Issues

At the moment, there are a few key issues that investors have in mind: manganese content, possible equity dilution, and the biggest issue, permitting.

Regarding the manganese content within the resource, management has already proven that there is an ongoing interest for its future concentrates from smelters and other offtake groups. A $13 per Metric Tonne penalty was also applied to the NPV calculation to account for the costs of separating the manganese from the ore.

As for equity dilution, Jim Gowans, President and CEO recently announced the company’s intent, “to fund the project with little to no equity.” He also added: “In light of the project's strong cash flow, we should be able to attract significant conventional debt ($250-$300 million), off-take financing ($75-$150 million) and a silver stream ($200-$350 million). We will minimize equity dilution wherever we can to benefit all shareholders.” 

As for permitting, James Gowans, President and CEO, announced plans to, “initiate state permitting for operations on our patented land and break ground on the tailings facility by the end of 2017.” He also added that, “Our permitting efforts are underpinned by strong existing local and state support built on early and extensive engagement."

Ultimately, approval for permitting will be at the discretion of the US Government but i am confident that AZ's management team will be able to work things out with the EPA, as this is a major product and would help to boost economic growth in Arizona.



Insider Buying

Immediately following the release of the PEA, Robert Wares, one of the directors at AZ, purchased 100’000 shares on the open market at an average price of $2.23. While insider buying can often serve as a catalyst for an upcoming switch in the market's direction,  investors must be very careful about reading positive messages into every insider buy that they see. While one big insider buy or sell order might offer investors a hint of things to come, it hardly translates into a sure-fire pointer for outperforming the market. It is important to look deeper at the order size, timing, and specific insider who made the purchase.

In this case, the purchase was from an independent director and professional geologist, Mr. Robert Wares. Wares has over 35 years of experience in the mining and exploration industry and his guiding hand on exploration has led to the ultimate discovery of over 13 million ounces of gold. This is one of the industry’s most well-known veterans making a large, strategically timed open market purchase.



A Life Cycle Analysis

The chart below show the performance of AZ's stock price since last January. 


A brief comparison of the Arizona Mining stock chart to the 'Life Cycle of a Mine' chart below should help you to gain a better understanding of the recent activity in the stock price. 

The 'Life Cycle of a Mine' chart displays the typical life cycle that a mining company will go through starting from the discovery/speculation phase up until the production phase.


Keep in mind that the 'life cycle of a mine' chart is overly simplistic and should not be used to time entries and exits into short-term positions, nor does it consider the possibility that the project will never reach the production stage. Rather, it should provide you with a broader view of how the average mining stock performs over the long term.

If we were to plot Arizona Mining’s current status on this chart, it would fall somewhere along the development/investment analysis phase line. The company has moved on from the discovery/speculation phase but has not yet reached production.

The discovery phase for AZ occurred all throughout 2016 and saw its share price rise from $0.30, to peak at $3.49 in December 2016, primarily due to a consistent waves of outstanding drill results and discoveries.

The first three months of 2017 marked the transition period from the discovery phase into the development phase. During this time, the stock price has fallen back below the $3 mark and has since been stuck in a narrow trading range around $2.20-2.40. Those in search of an explanation should refer to the mining life cycle chart, as a decline in stock price during this transition is a natural movement in the life cycle of a mining company and comes as a result of investor speculation and profit-taking with regards to a PEA or feasibility study. It is quite clear that investors are not worried about the size and grade of the deposit anymore, rather, they are more concerned with the roadblocks that the company will need to get past on the path to reaching the production stage.



The Bottom Line

Due to a lack of available short term catalysts, I don't foresee any dramatic short-term movements in the price of AZ stock. However, what I do see is a long term convergence between the current share price [$2.22] and the project’s NPV [$6.75]. Under the assumption of no further equity dilution, the shares of Arizona Mining are trading for a ~66% discount to their true value. I believe that an overstatement of the relevant risk factors has led to an overly aggressive discount to NPV. While there are a number of issues that still remain, the AZ management team has done an excellent job to address those issues.

A second scenario that I am envisioning is a potential takeover offer from a tier-1 producer such as BHP, Rio Tinto, or Hudbay. The Hermosa-Taylor deposit exhibits very attractive metrics and will be a sought-after project for producers looking to fatten up their balance sheets. Historically, takeover bids for junior and mid-cap mining stocks typically have carried a 38%-54% premium to market, so in the case of Arizona Mining, I would expect the offer price to be between the $5-7 per share range.

The fact is that there is a large discrepancy between the intrinsic value of the Hermosa-Taylor project and the share price of Arizona Mining. Over time, as the mine edges closer to production, the various risks factors will be greatly reduced, and so will the discount to NPV. The markets lack of response to the positive PEA results is presenting value investors with a significant opportunity. 

 

DISCLOSURE & DISCLAIMER

The author is long AZ.

The author is NOT a registered investment advisor and this article expresses their own opinions. All readers are encouraged to perform their own due diligence and consult a licensed investment advisor before making any investment decisions. The author is not receiving compensation for the article and has no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned. This article is provided for information purposes.

Investments appearing in this article are high-risk in nature. Because of significant volatility, large dealer spreads and very limited market liquidity, typically you will not be able to sell a low priced security immediately back to the dealer at the same price it sold the stock to you. In some cases, the stock may fall quickly in value. You should carefully consider whether trading in low priced and international securities is suitable for you in light of your circumstances and financial resources. Past performance is no guarantee of future returns.

JSC LOGO BLACK BARS PNG.png

CONTACT US

E-mail:

Social:

  • Twitter
  • Discord
  • Whatsapp
  • YouTube
  • Instagram

SUBSCRIBE NOW

You are now subscribed to SmallCapInvestor.ca

DISCLAIMER

This is the official website of SmallCapInvestor (“SmallCapInvestor” or the “Creator”).

Please read the following terms and conditions of website use (the “terms and conditions”) carefully before accessing or using the Creator’s website as they represent a binding agreement between you (either an individual or a single entity) and the Creator and govern your use of www.smallcapinvestor.ca together with all of the information and materials available on such website (collectively, “This Site” or “www.smallcapinvestor.ca”). By accessing, browsing or using This Site, you agree to be bound by the terms and conditions as outlined herein. If you have not read, do not understand, or do not agree to be bound by these terms and conditions, please do not use This Site. The Creator reserves the right to change these terms and conditions from time to time at its sole discretion and without notice.

It is your responsibility to check for any updates, and you should revisit this page from time to time as your use of This Site is subject to the most current version of the terms and conditions posted at the time of such use.

The Creator has taken all reasonable care in producing and publishing information contained on This Site and will endeavour to do so regularly. However, material on This Site may still contain technical or other inaccuracies, omissions, or typographical errors, for which the Creator assumes no responsibility. Under no circumstances shall the Creator be liable for any direct, indirect, special, incidental, consequential or other damages, including but not limited to, loss of programs, loss of data, loss of use of computer or other systems, or loss of profits, whether or not advised of the possibility of damage arising from your use, or inability to use, the material on This Site. Further, you may not modify or reproduce in any form, electronic or otherwise, any information on This Site.

Your rights to use This Site

Provided that you accept and comply with these terms and conditions, you have the limited right to access and use This Site to view the various materials, including information, documents and other content on This Site and to copy, download or print a single copy of any of the information and materials available on it, solely for your personal non-commercial use or your internal informational use in business and not for resale or distribution to anyone else, provided that you reproduce all of the Creator’s proprietary markings on each copy of reproduced material. Except as expressly permitted by the Creator in writing, you may not copy, reproduce, download, upload, post, transmit, translate, modify, distribute, sell, rent, license, transfer, mirror, frame or create derivative works from This Site, in whole or in part, in any form or by any means. 

Do Not Use Any Information in Our Publications to Make an Investment Decision

We are paid advertisers and we are publishers of publicly disseminated information on behalf of our clients, publicly traded companies, or non-affiliate third party shareholders of various issuers (“Client Companies”). Do not base an investment decision on any of the contents of our publications on This Site.

We are not registered as and we do not act, directly or indirectly, in the capacity of any of the following and you should not construe our activities as involving advice from any of the following: (a) an investment advisor; (b) a broker dealer; (c) a broker; (d) a dealer; (e) a stock recommender; (f) a stock picker; (g) a finder; (h) a securities trading expert; (i) a financial planner; (j) a securities analyst; or (k) a financial analyst.

The information found on This Site was prepared without regard to any particular investor’s investment objectives, financial situation, or financial or investment needs. Accordingly, investors should not act on any information contained on This Site without obtaining specific advice from their financial advisors and should not rely on information herein as the basis for their investment decisions. Investments based on the information provided on www.smallcapinvestor.cainvolve a substantial risk of loss and are not appropriate for everyone. No representation is being made that utilizing the information on www.smallcapinvestor.ca will result in profitable trading or be free of risk of loss. Before deciding to trade or invest you should carefully consider your investment objectives, level of experience, and ability to tolerate risk. The possibility exists that you could sustain a loss of some or all of your investment. 

Forward-Looking Information

Certain information contained on www.smallcapinvestor.ca, including any information as to the future financial or operating performance of the Client Companies highlighted, may be deemed “forward looking”. All statements on www.smallcapinvestor.ca, other than statements of historical fact, which address events or developments is expected to occur, are “forward-looking statements” or “forward-looking information”. Generally, these forward-looking statements can be identified by the use of forward-looking terminology, including but not limited to, the words “expects”, “does not expect”, “plans”, “anticipates”, “does not anticipate”, “believes”, “intends”, “estimates”, “projects”, “potential”, “scheduled”, “forecast”, “budget” and similar expressions or their negative connotations, or that events or conditions “will”, “would”, “may”, “could”, “should” or “might” occur. 

All such forward-looking statements are subject to important risk factors and uncertainties, many of which are beyond the ability to control or predict. Forward-looking statements are necessarily based on estimates and assumptions that are inherently subject to known and unknown risks, uncertainties and other factors that may cause Client Companies’ actual results, level of activity, performance or achievements to be materially different from those expressed or implied by such forward-looking statements.

Forward-looking statements are not guarantees of future performance, and actual results and future events could materially differ from those anticipated in such statements. All of the forward-looking statements contained on www.smallcapinvestor.ca are qualified by these cautionary statements. The Creator expressly disclaims any intent or obligation to update or revise any forward-looking statements, whether as a result of new information, events or otherwise, except in accordance with applicable securities laws.

Indemnity

To the maximum extent permitted by applicable law, you will defend, indemnify and hold harmless the Creator, and its respective directors, officers, employees, consultants and agents from and against all claims, liability, and expenses, including all legal fees and costs, arising out of your breach of any provision of these terms and conditions or, any applicable law or proprietary or privacy right in connection therewith. The Creator reserves the right, in its sole discretion and at its own expense, to assume the exclusive defence and control of any matter otherwise subject to indemnification by you. You will co-operate as fully as reasonably required in the defence of any claim.

Stock Quotes

All stock price quotes and historical stock price data on This Site are provided by third parties, are for informational purposes only, and are not intended for trading purposes. If you are contemplating trading in securities of companies mentioned on www.smallcapinvestor.ca, the Creator strongly advises that you obtain independent professional advice (including independent legal and financial advice from qualified advisors) before making any investment decision. The Creator makes no representation or warranty regarding the timeliness, accuracy or completeness of any stock price quotes or historical stock price data.

Laws

This Site (excluding linked sites) is controlled by the Creator from its offices within the Province of British Columbia, Canada. By accessing This Site, you and the Creator agree that all matters relating to your access to, or use of, This Site shall be governed by the statutes and laws of the Province of British Columbia or the federal laws of Canada, as applicable, without regard to the conflicts of laws principles thereof. You and the Creator also agree and hereby submit to the exclusive personal jurisdiction and venue of the courts of the Province of British Columbia with respect to any and all matters arising in connection with these terms and conditions. 

Third Party Links 

The Creator has provided links from This Site to several other websites (“Third Party Websites”) that are arm’s-length to the Creator, and may embed content from Third Party Websites on This Site. The viewer should be aware that in linking to Third Party Websites they are leaving This Site and the Creator is not responsible for the content of any Third Party Website. Information on Third Party Websites, and any information from Third party Websites embedded on This Site, may be updated, revised, or otherwise modified without the knowledge or involvement of the Creator.  The Creator expressly disclaims any and all responsible for the accuracy of the content on any Third Party Websites, whether on This Site or not. 

bottom of page